I think it's a kid-friendly meal. There's pasta. There's melted cheese. I think it could be a win with the Goatlings.
The older Goatling probably had it before, and I have no recollection if she liked it or not, though that may not stop from addressing any reluctance to try the Garbage Plate with the (oft-used) phrase, "You had it before! And you liked it! Really!" Though the kids never seem to believe me when I tell them they USED to like it, and it doesn't seem to make any impact on whether they like it NOW.
But, I like it, I've always liked it, and I'm confidant I'll like it again, so let's make it!